I Refused to Give My Friend an Excellent Performance Review at Work… So She Accused Me of Being Jealous of Her!
🌐 Machine-translated content Read original text ↗
My friend and I worked together at the same company, and now I’m in charge of a team she’s part of. Our relationship outside work is great, and she’s never asked me for a favor. When it was time for the annual review, I found that her performance was good, but not among the top three on the team. I wrote an honest review and mentioned areas she needed to improve. I was surprised when she got really upset and told me she’d expected me to support her, at the very least, after all these years of friendship. She said, “You know I’m going through a hard time, and this review will affect my raise.” I really do know what she’s going through, but if I gave her a higher rating, I’d be treating other people who worked harder unfairly. Now she isn’t answering my calls, and our colleagues think I could have been gentler in how I wrote it. Question: Does friendship require you to be flexible when evaluating someone’s performance? For discussion: Can you be your friend’s manager without losing the friendship?
Discussion